Native American Renaissance - Criticism

Criticism

The term Native American Renaissance has been criticized on a number of points. As James Ruppert writes, "Scholars hesitate to use the phrase because it might imply that Native writers were not producing significant work before that time, or that these writers sprang up without longstanding community and tribal roots. Indeed, if this was a rebirth, what was the original birth?" Other critics have described it as "a source of controversy," or have commented on its "vexing implications" of a comparative downgrading of the artistry of oral tradition.