Titleholders
| Year | Titleholder | Hometown |
|---|---|---|
| 2013 | Raylene Mackey | Goulds |
| 2012 | Emily Bland | Grand Falls-Windsor |
| 2011 | Chelsea Butler | Conception Bay South |
| 2010 | Georgina Barbour | Witless Bay |
| 2010 | Somaria Balram | St. John's |
| 2009 | Chelsea Squires | Burin |
| 2008 | Laura Woodworth | Grand Falls-Windsor |
| 2007 | Danielle Seward | Heart's Delight-Islington |
| 2006 | Sabrina Fitzpatrick | Kilbride |
| 2005 | Nikita Hickey | Grand le Pierre |
| 2004 | Melissa Jenkins | Carbonear |
| 2004 | Renée Hodder | Mount Pearl |
| 2003 | Ashley Bursey | St. John's |
| 2002 | Kristen Parsons | Wabush |
| 2001 | Natalie Langor | Corner Brook |
| 2000 | Arlene O'Keefe | Paradise |
| 1999 | Crystal Freake | Grand Falls-Windsor |
| 1999 | Melanie O'Brien | Paradise |
| 1998 | Christa Borden | Chamberlains |
| 1997 | Kathleen Bradbury | Mount Pearl |
- In 2010, winner Somaria Balram left the province to pursue post-secondary education in Nova Scotia, resulting in 1st runner-up Georgina Barbour assuming the title in August 2010.
- In 2004, winner Renée Hodder elected to not sign the titleholder agreement, resulting in 1st runner-up Melissa Jenkins (Carbonear) assuming the title in October 2004.
- In 1999, Crystal Freake was the winner of the Miss Teen Canada International title, resulting in the 1st runner-up Melanie O'Brien (Paradise) assuming the provincial title.
Read more about this topic: Miss Teen Newfoundland & Labrador Pageant