Table
= Historian | = Poli Sci | = Research |
Author | Nat | Volhynia | Galicia | VOL+GAL | V+G+P | E. POL | Source | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Timothy Snyder | 50k | - | - | - | In Past and Present | |||
"" "" | >40k | 10k | - | - | Memory and Power, 2002 | 10k is in March '44, >40k in July '43 | ||
"" "" | 40-60k in '43 | 25k | - | 5k | The Reconstruction of Nations, 2004 | 5k is Lublin and Rzeszów; "killed by UPA" | ||
Grzegorz Motyka | 40-60k | - | - | 80-100k | 6-8k | W kręgu Łun w Bieszczadach, 2009, page 13 | net is from '43 to '47 | |
"" "" | 40-60k | 30-40k | - | 100k | Od rzezi wołyńskiej do akcji "Wisła", 2011, pages 447-448 | |||
Ivan Katchanovski | 35-60k | - | - | - | Terrorists or National Heroes? Politics of the OUN and the UPA in Ukraine | Katchanovski considers the lower bound 35k to be more likely; cited Snyder, Hrytsiuk | ||
Grzegorz Hryciuk | 35-60k | - | - | - | "Vtraty naselennia na Volyni u 1941-1944rr." Ukraina-Polshcha: Vazhki Pytannia, Vol. 5. Warsaw: Tyrsa, 2001 | Cited by Katchanovski | ||
"" "" | 35.7-60k | - | - | - | Hryciuk G. Przemiany narodowosciowe i ludnosciowe w Galicji Wschodniej i na Wolyniu w latach 1931–1948 / G. Hryciuk. – Torun, 2005. – S. 279. | Cited by Kalischuk | ||
"" "" | - | 20-24 | - | - | Straty ludnosci w Galicji Wschodniej w latach 1941–1945 / G. Hryciuk // Polska–Ukraina: trudne pytania. – Warszawa, 2000. – T. 6. – S. 279, 290, 294. | Cited by Kalischuk; from 43-46; 8820 in '43-mid'44; "according to relevant contemporary Polish sources" | ||
"" "" | 35.7-60k | 20-25k | - | G.Hryciuk, Przemiany narodowosciowe i ludnosciowe w Galicji Wschodniej i na Wolyniu w latach 1931–1948, Toruń 2005, pp.279,315 | for Galicia "primary balance" relied on "fragmentary and often incomplete documentation" and witnesses' testimonies | |||
P.R. Magocsi | - | - | - | 50k | Magocsi; A History of Ukraine, p 681 | “among the more reasonable estimates" | ||
Niall Fergusson | - | - | 60-80k | - | The war of the world, 2007 | Fergusson is citing other authors (which ones?) | ||
John Paul Himka | - | - | 100k | - | Interventions: Challenging the Myths of Twentieth-Century Ukrainian history, 2001 | |||
Per Anders Rudling | 40-70k | - | - | 7k | Theory and Practice, 2006 | Problems with Rudling noted below | ||
Rossolinski-Liebe | - | - | 70-100k | - | The Ukrainian national revolution (2011), Celebrating Fascism... (2010) | I'm having trouble finding the actual source - it may be referred to here. | ||
Ewa Siemaszko | 60k | 70k | 130k | 133k | Bilans zbrodni, 2010 | According Rudling it is most extensive study of the Polish casualties (Rudling, "The OUN, the UPA and the Holocaust...", p. 50) | ||
Marek Jasiak | - | - | - | 60-70k | Redrawing Nations, p174 | "In Podole, Volhynia, and Lublin" | ||
Terles | 50k | 60-70k | - | 100-200k | In Ethnic Cleansing p61 | |||
Karta | 35k | 29.8k | - | - | 6.5k | "Polska-Ukraina", t.7, 2000, p. 159, cited by Kalishchuk: here | Karta based mostly on: Siemaszko for Volhynia (documented number) and Cz.Blicharski for Tarnopol voivodsh. | |
Katarina Wolczuk | - | - | - | 60-100k | “The Difficulties of Polish–Ukrainian Historical Reconciliation,” paper published by the Royal Institute of International Affairs, London, 2002, cited by Marples | |||
Alexander Gogun | 25k+ | - | - | Historian @ Postdam, Research fellow @ Harvard | ||||
Common communicate of PL and UKR historians | 50-60k | 20-25k | - | 5-6k | "Polska-Ukraina: trudne pytania", 2000, t. 9, p. 403. | "Polish caualties acc. to Polish sources" | ||
Ryszard Torzecki | 30-40k | 30-40k | 80-100k | 10-20k (Polesie i Lublin) | R. Torzecki, Polacy i Ukraińcy. Sprawa ukraińska podczas II wojny światowej na terenie II Rzeczypospolitej, 1993, p. 267 | |||
IPN | 60-80k | - | - | - | Oddziałowa Komisja w Lublinie, January 2012 | killed by Ukrainian nationalists, 1939-1945? | ||
Norman Davies | - | - | - | hundreds of thousands | 'God's playground. A history of Poland', Oxford University Press, 2005, p. 350 | ethnic cleansing | ||
Czesław Partacz | - | - | - | 134-200k | Przemilczane w ukraińskiej historiografii przyczyny ludobójstwa popełnionego przez OUN-UPA na ludności polskiej Prawda historyczna na prawda polityczna w badaniach naukowych. Przykład ludobójstwa na Kresach Południowo-Wschodniej Polski w latach 1939-1946, Bogusław Paź (edition), Wrocław 2011 | |||
Lucyna Kulińska | - | - | - | 150-200k | "Dzieci Kresów III", Kraków 2009, p. 467 | |||
Anna M. Cienciala | - | - | 40-60k | The Rebirth of Poland. University of Kansas, lecture notes by professor Anna M. Cienciala, 2004 | During WWII, the Bandera faction of the Ukrainian Insurrectionary Army (UPA) murdered 40,000-60,000 Poles living in the villages of former Volhynia and former East Galicia | |||
Pertti Ahonen et al. | - | - | 100,000 | Pertti Ahonen, Gustavo Corni, Jerzy Kochanowski, Rainer Schulze, Tamás Stark, Barbara Stelzl-Marx, People on the Move: Population Transfers and Ethnic Cleansing Policies During World War II and Its Aftermath. Berg Publishers. 2008. p. 99. | 100,000 killed+300,000 refugees (in ethnic cleansing conducted by Ukrainian nationalists) |
Author | Nat | Volhynia | Galicia | VOL+GAL | V+G+P | E. POL | Source | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Grzegorz Motyka | 2-3k | - | - | 10-20k | 8-12k | W kregu łun w Bieszczadach, Rytm 2009, page 13 | 1943-1947, The number for total includes those killed in Volhynia, Galicia, territories of present day (eastern) Poland | ||
"" "" | 2-3k | 1-2k | - | 10/11-15k | 8-10k | Od rzezi wołyńskiej do akcji "Wisła", 2011, page 448 | 1943-1947; According to Motyka, numbers of Ukrainian casualties from hands of Poles >= 30k are "simply pulled out of thin air". | ||
"" "" | - | - | 8.3k | 15-20k | 10-12k | "Polish reaction to the actions of the UPA: the scope and course of punitive" p28 2003 | Cited by Kalishchuk; period 1943-1948 | ||
P.A. Rudling | 20k | - | +11k | in "Historical Representation of the Wartime Accounts of the Activities of the OUN..." | Cites Maksymiuk “Ukraine, Poland Seek Reconciliation
Over Grisly History.” |
||||
P. R. Magocsi | - | - | 20k | Magocsi; A History of Ukraine, p 681 | “among the more reasonable estimates" | ||||
T. Snyder | 10k | - | - | Past and Present | "Over the course of 1943, perhabs ten thousand Ukrainian civilians were killed by Polish self-defence units, Soviet partisans, Nazi policemen". | ||||
"" "" | - | - | - | +5k | The reconstruction of nations | in Lublin and Rzeszów | |||
Rossolinski-Liebe | - | - | 10-20k | Celebrating Fascism... | both UPA members and civilians, during and after the war. Rossolinski cites Motyka's estimation of 2006. | ||||
Katarina Wolczuk | - | - | 15-30k | UK scholar. Cited by Marples. | |||||
Katrina Witt | - | - | 15-30k | Ukrainian Memory and Victimhood, p101 | Cited Marples, who cites Wolczuk. | ||||
Karta | unknown | unknown | - | 7.5k | "Polska-Ukraina", t.7, 2000, p. 159, cited by Kalishchuk: here | ||||
Zashkilniak L. and M. Krykun | ? | - | - | 35k | Zashkilniak L., M. Krykun History of Poland: from ancient times to the present day / L. Over- Shkilnyak - Lviv, 2002. - p. 527 | Cited by Kalishchuk. | |||
Alexander Gogun | 10k+ | - | - | Historian @ Postdam, Research fellow @ Harvard | |||||
Anna M. Cienciala | - | - | - | 20k | - | The Rebirth of Poland. University of Kansas, lecture notes by professor Anna M. Cienciala, 2004 | ...the Poles killed some 20,000 Ukrainians, mostly in former East Galicia in reprisal. |
Read more about this topic: Massacres Of Poles In Volhynia, Number of Victims
Famous quotes containing the word table:
“When you got to the table you couldnt go right to eating, but you had to wait for the widow to tuck down her head and grumble a little over the victuals, though there warnt really anything the matter with them. That is, nothing only everything was cooked by itself. In a barrel of odds and ends it is different; things get mixed up, and the juice kind of swaps around, and the things go better.”
—Mark Twain [Samuel Langhorne Clemens] (18351910)
“They were not on the table with their elbows.
They were not sleeping in the shelves of bunks.
I saw no men there and no bones of men there.”
—Robert Frost (18741963)
“When he was at the table with them, he took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to them. Then their eyes were opened, and they recognized him; and he vanished from their sight.”
—Bible: New Testament, Luke 24:30,31.
The Emmaus story.