Holding
The Court held that Congress had the authority to void treaty obligations with Native American tribes because it had an inherent "plenary power":
Authority over the tribal relations of the Indians has been exercised by Congress from the beginning, and the power has always been deemed a political one, not subject to be controlled by the judicial department of the government. —Lone Wolf at 565.The decision was based, among other things, on a paternalistic view of the United States' relationship with the tribes:
These Indian tribes are the wards of the nation. They are communities dependent on the United States. Dependent largely for their daily food. Dependent for their political rights. They own no allegiance to the states, and receive from them no protection. Because of the local ill feeling, the people of the states where they are found are often their deadliest enemies. From their very weakness and helplessness, so largely due to the course of dealing of the Federal government with them and the treaties in which it has been promised, there arises the duty of protection, and with it the power. This has always been recognized by the executive and by Congress, and by this court, whenever the question has arisen. —Lone Wolf at 567, quoting United States v. Kagama, 118 U.S. 375 (1885).Congress unilaterally modified many other treaties between Native American tribes and the United States in subsequent years, in part relying on the decision in Lone Wolf v. Hitchcock. The decision has been upheld and cited by the Supreme Court since then, such as in United States v. Dion of 1986.
Read more about this topic: Lone Wolf V. Hitchcock
Famous quotes containing the word holding:
“But it is the same thing we are all seeing,
Our world. Go after it,
Go get it boy, says the man holding the stick.
Eat, says the hunger, and we plunge blindly in again,
Into the chamber behind the thought.”
—John Ashbery (b. 1927)
“The child hand raised to reach the holding hand. Hold the old holding hand. Hold and be held.”
—Samuel Beckett (19061989)
“An inquiry about the attitude towards the release of so-called political prisoners. I should be very sorry to see the United States holding anyone in confinement on account of any opinion that that person might hold. It is a fundamental tenet of our institutions that people have a right to believe what they want to believe and hold such opinions as they want to hold without having to answer to anyone for their private opinion.”
—Calvin Coolidge (18721933)