P
- John Panelli, football player
- Joe Paterno, football coach
- Vinny Pazienza, boxer
- Vincent Pazzetti, football player
- Willie Pep, boxer
- Cavino Michelli Petillo, racing driver
- Johnny Petraglia, bowler
- Rico Petrocelli, baseball player
- Harry Pezzullo, golfer
- Brian Piccolo, football player
- Ralph "Babe" Pinelli, baseball player
- Rick Pitino, basketball coach
- Angelo Poffo, wrestler
- Mike Piazza, baseball player
Read more about this topic: List Of Members Of The Italian American Sports Hall Of Fame