- 1602–1606: Nicholas Stephenson
- ? to 1621: Reverend John Watson
- 1627–1632: Reverend Thomas Cooper
- 1632–1638: Nicholas Davie
- 1638: Reverend Thomas Cooper (again)
- 1638–1639: Henry Luce
- 1640: Henry Luce (again)
- 1640–1643: Timothy Cutler
- 1643–1644: Reverend Thomas Cooper (again) - hanged in 1650 as a Royalist rebel
- 1658–1660: Reverend Henry Mazy
- 1661–1665: Reverend John Goodman
- 1689–1692: Thomas Kellway
- 1692: William Chambers
- 1692–1695: Thomas Garrett
- 1695: William Rowland
- 1696–1697: Thomas Turner
- 1697–1704: Thomas Plumstead
|
- 1705–1708: John Reynolds
- 1708: John Fox
- 1708–1713: William Selth
- 1713–1714: John Spurling
- 1714–1715: William Chaplyn
- c. 1718: John Brooke
- c. 1725: John Holmes
- 1729: Edward Read
- 1770s: Christopher Stangroom
- 1796–1801: David Kinnebrook
- 1810–1811: Reverend Robert Davies
- 1811–1813: Peter Barney
- 1813–1821: Daniel Carr
- 1821: James Sturley
- 1821–1828: Reverend Thomas Beckwith
- 1828–1843: Reverend William Robert Taylor
- 1843–1851: John Slann (first Second Master)
|