I
| Name/Animal type | Birthday | Introduced | Retired | Other | Photo |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I Love U the Bear | 2/19/05 | 11/30/05 | 2/24/06 | ||
| Icecubes the Polar bear | NONE | 1/01/06 | 2/01/06 | January 2006 Beanie Baby of the Month | |
| Icepack the Polar Bear | NONE | 11/02/05 | 3/16/06 | ||
| Icing the Seal | 12/18/04 | 10/31/05 | CURRENT | ||
| Iggy the Iguana | 8/12/97 | 1/01/99 | 3/31/99 | Early releases were mistakenly mislabeled "Rainbow." In all, a total of three versions of Iggy were made. Differences include their fabric, spikes, and tongue. | |
| Illinois the Bear | NONE | 8/30/04 | 12/29/05 | Exclusive to Illinois | |
| Illinois Violet the Bear | NONE | 7/23/05 | 12/29/05 | Exclusive to Illinois | |
| Inch the Inchworm | 9/03/95 | 6/03/95 | 5/01/98 | Two versions made, one with felt and one with yarn antennas. Was #4 in 1998 Teenie Beanie series. Made as Beanie Buddy in 1999. | |
| Independence the Bear | 7/04/06 | 4/28/06 | 10/25/06 | Three versions made, each with a different paw color (red, white, and blue) and other differences | |
| India the tiger | 5/26/00 | 6/24/00 | 6/12/01 | One of the first beanies to be made with the head facing to the side, a short design trend that started around 2000 | |
| Inky the octopus | 11/29/94 | 6/25/94 | 5/01/98 | Made in two colors: gray and pink. Some gray versions did not have a mouth | |
| Ireland the Bear | 12/17/04 | 12/30/04 | 3/27/06 | United Kingdom exclusive | |
| Issy the Bear | NONE | 3/01/01 | 12/31/01 | Made in memory of Christopher Sharp, son of Four Seasons Hotel founder Isadore Sharp, who died of cancer. Released in 63 locations around the world (see complete list). | |
| It's a Boy the Bear | NONE | 1/30/04 | 3/30/05 | ||
| It's a Girl the Bear | NONE | 1/30/04 | 3/30/05 |
Read more about this topic: List Of Beanie Babies