Awards/nominations
| Year | Group | Award | Result | Recipient(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2002 | PPFA Maggie Awards | Maggie Award for Media Excellence ("The Third Horseman") | Won | |
| People's Choice Award | Best New Series | Nominated | ||
| Image Award | Outstanding Actor in a Drama Series | Nominated | Courtney B. Vance | |
| 2003 | Edgar Award | Best Television Episode | Nominated | René Balcer |
| 2004 | Satellite Award | Best Actor in a Series, Drama | Nominated | Vincent D'Onofrio |
| Edgar Award | Best Episode in a Television Series Teleplay | Nominated | René Balcer and Gerry Conway, |
|
| 2005 | Edgar Award | Best Episode in a Television Series Teleplay | Won | René Balcer and Elizabeth Benjamin, |
| Edgar Award | Best Episode in a Television Series Teleplay | Nominated | René Balcer and Gerry Conway, ; René Balcer and Warren Leight, ; René Balcer and Warren Leight, |
|
| 2006 | Reims International Television Festival | Best Drama Episode ("In the Wee Small Hours") | Nominated | |
| Banff Television Award | Best Drama ("In The Wee Small Hours") | Nominated | ||
| ALMA Award | Outstanding Director of a Television Drama or Comedy | Nominated | Norberto Barba | |
| 2008 | Edgar Award | Best Television Episode Teleplay | Nominated | Warren Leight, Siobhan Byrne, & Julie Martin |
| Image Award | Outstanding Directing in a Drama Series | Nominated | Darnell Martin |
|
| Satellite Award | Best Actress in a Series, Drama | Nominated | Kathryn Erbe | |
| ALMA Award | Outstanding Director of a Television Drama or Comedy | Nominated | Norberto Barba |
Read more about this topic: Law & Order: Criminal Intent