Laura Albert - Fraud Charges

Fraud Charges

In June 2007, Albert was sued by Antidote International Films Inc. for fraud, which claims that a contract signed with JT Leroy to make a feature film of Sarah is null and void. On June 22, 2007, Laura Albert was found guilty of fraud by a Manhattan jury, and ordered to pay $110,000 to Antidote, as well as an extra $6,500 in punitive damages.

In August 2008, the Authors Guild released an amicus brief in regards to the trial verdict, supporting Laura and opposing the jury’s decision, stating that the decision “will have negative repercussions extending into the future for many authors. The right to free speech, and the right to speak and write anonymously are rights protected by our Constitution, and the district court's decision which holds that Laura Albert's use of pseudonym breached the Option and Purchase Agreement, is one that will have a chilling effect upon authors wishing to exercise their right to write anonymously.” They go on to request that the court reverse the decision in regards to a breach of contract.

According to the Amicus Brief, Albert's "reveal" by the New York Times raises into question the extent to which an author can maintain not only a pseudonym in his/her byline, but also to create an embodiment and persona to claim authorship to the work. Albert said in a 2006 interview in The Paris Review that she was able to maintain her voice and perspective by remaining in the shadows: "I could get what I wanted—connecting with others—without having to be the focus of attention."

Albert did not publish her writing as "memoir" - she published her writing as "fiction." Although fans may have felt betrayed by the lack of authenticity when it was revealed that she was female and over 20 years older than her main character, there is a legacy of female authors using male pseudonyms for the sake of their work, including the Brontë Sisters, George Eliot and Louisa May Alcott.

Albert attests that she could not have written from raw emotion without the right to be presented to the world via JT Leroy, who she calls her phantom limb - a style of performance art she had been undertaking to deal with experiences even as a little girl, according to a 2006 interview in the Paris Review.

In November 2010, Laura Albert appeared at The Moth to tell her story on video.

In August 2011, there was a window installation about Laura Albert at Artists' Television Access.