All-Americans (16)
- Jeff Keller, DE – 1967 American Football Coaches Association
- Chris Hicks, OT – 1975 American Football Coaches Association
- Vincent Allen, RB – 1976 American Football Coaches Association
- Ed Martin, DE – 1983 American Football Coaches Association
- Wayne Davis, DB – 1984 American Football Coaches Association
- Vencie Glenn, DB – 1985 American Football Coaches Association
- Mike Simmonds, OT – 1986 American Football Coaches Association
- Derrick Franklin, RB – 1991 Walter Camp, The Sports Network
- Shawn Moore, OG – 1993 American Football Coaches Association
- Dan Brandenburg, DT – 1994 American Football Coaches Association
- Dan Brandenburg, DT – 1995 The Sports Network, American Football Quarterly
- Tom Allison, PK – 1995 Don Hansen’s Football Gazette
- Troy Lefevra, DE – 1998 Don Hansen’s Football Gazette
- DeJuan Alfonzo, DB/RS – 1999 American Football Coaches Association
- Shakir Bell, RB - 2011 Associated Press, American Football Coaches Association, The Sports Network
- Ben Obaseki, DL - 2011 Associated Press
Read more about this topic: Indiana State Sycamores Football