Contestants
| Nickname | Real Name | Eliminated |
|---|---|---|
| Tailor Made | George Weisgerber | 13 !Winner |
| Buddha | Ezra Masters | 12 !Episode 12 |
| Punk | David Otunga | 10 !Episode 10 |
| The Entertainer | Frank Maresca | 09 !Episode 9 |
| Mr. Wise | Solomon | 08 !Episode 8 |
| Pretty | Juan | 07 !Episode 7 (Quit) |
| Wolf | Greg | 06 !Episode 6 |
| It | Kwame Smalls | 05 !Episode 5 |
| Midget Mac | Torrey | 05 !Episode 5 |
| 20 Pack | Nico | 04 !Episode 4 |
| Cheezy | Matthew Levy | 03 !Episode 3 |
| Man Man | Collin | 03 !Episode 3 |
| Knock Out | Deandre | 02 !Episode 2 |
| Unsure | Jared | 02 !Episode 2 (Quit) |
| Yours | Lafayette | 02 !Episode 2 |
| Champion | Jimmy | 01 !Episode 1 |
| Doc | Dwight | 01 !Episode 1 |
| Ears | David | 01 !Episode 1 |
| Milliown | Jamal | 01 !Episode 1 |
| Sweetie Pie | Darnell | 01 !Episode 1 |
- ^ Buddha was eliminated in Episode 4 for violence, was brought back in Episode 5, and was runner up.
Read more about this topic: I Love New York 2