Contestants
| Name | Original Show | Team | Eliminated |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hoopz (Nicole Alexander) | Flavor of Love | Gold | 16 !Winner |
| Whiteboy (Joshua Gallander) | I Love New York | Green | 15 !Episode 13 (2nd) |
| Megan Hauserman | Rock of Love 2 | Green | 14 !Episode 13 (3rd) (QUIT) |
| Real (Ahmad Givens) | I Love New York | Green | 13 !Episode 13 (4th) |
| Pumkin (Brooke Thompson) | Flavor of Love | Gold | 12 !Episode 11 (5th) |
| Toasteee (Jennifer Toof) | Flavor of Love 2 | Gold | 11 !Episode 11 |
| Brandi Cunningham | Rock of Love | Green | 10 !Episode 10 (QUIT) |
| The Entertainer (Frank Maresca) | I Love New York 2 | Gold | 10 !Episode 10 |
| Heather Chadwell | Rock of Love | Gold | 09 !Episode 9 |
| 12 Pack (David Amerman) | I Love New York | Gold | 08 !Episode 8 |
| Rodeo (Cindy Steedle) | Rock of Love | Gold | 07 !Episode 7 |
| Chance (Kamal Givens) | I Love New York | Green | 06 !Episode 6 |
| Destiney Sue Moore | Rock of Love 2 | Green | 05 !Episode 5 |
| Mr. Boston (Lee Marks) | I Love New York | Green | 04 !Episode 4 |
| Heat (Jason Rosell) | I Love New York | Green | 03 !Episode 3 |
| Nibblz (Domenique Majors) | Flavor of Love 2 | Gold | 02 !Episode 2 |
| Midget Mac (Torrey Samuels) | I Love New York 2 | No Team | 01 !Episode 1 |
- The contestants competed as teams (Green and Gold) from Episode 2 to 7, and competed as individuals from Episode 8 to 13 (Episode 12 excluded).
- Toastee was eliminated during the night that began in Episode 10 and concluded in Episode 11. Her actual elimination was shown in Episode 11, as Episode 10 ended on a cliffhanger.
- Brandi C & Megan quit the competition.
Read more about this topic: I Love Money (season 1)