- 17th c.
- Solomon Stoddard, 1667-1672
- Samuel Sewall, 1674
- Daniel Gookin, 1674–1676, 1679-1681
- Daniel Allin, 1676-1679
- John Cotton, 1681-1690
- Henry Newman, 1690-1693
- Ebenezer Pemberton, 1693-1697
- Nathaniel Saltonstall, 1697-1701
- 18th c.
- Anthony Stoddard, 1701-1702
- Josiah Willard, 1702-1703
- John Whiting, 1703-1706
- John Gore, 1706-1707
- Nathaniel Gookin, 1707-1709
- Edward Holyoke, 1709-1712
- Thomas Robie, 1712-1713
- John Denison, 1713-1714
- John Rogers, 1714-1718
- William Welsteed, 1718-1720
- William Cooke, 1720-1721
- Joshua Gee, 1721-1722
|
- Mitchell Sewall, 1722-1723
- John Hancock, 1723-1726
- Stephen Sewall, 1726-1728
- Joseph Champney, 1728-1729
- Joseph Pynchon, 1729-1730
- Henry Gibbs, 1730-1734
- Samuel Coolidge, 1734-1735
- James Diman, 1735-1737
- Samuel Cooke, 1737
- Thomas Marsh, 1737-1741
- Belcher Hancock, 1741-1742
- Benjamin Prat, 1742-1743
- Matthew Cushing, 1743-1748
- Oliver Peabody, 1748-1750
- Stephen Badger, 1751-1753
- John Rand, 1753-1755
- Mather Byles, 1755-1757
- Elizur Holyoke, 1757-1758
- Edward Brooks, 1758-1760
- Samuel Deane, 1760-1762
- Stephen Sewall, 1762-1763
- Andrew Eliot, 1763-1767
- Jonathan Moore, 1767-1768
|
- Nathaniel Ward, 1768
- Caleb Prentice, 1768-1769
- William Mayhew, 1769-1772
- James Winthrop, 1772-1787
- Isaac Smith, 1787-1791
- Thaddeus Mason Harris, 1787, 1791-1793
- Samuel Shapleigh, 1793-1800
- 19th c.
- Sidney Willard, 1800-1805
- Peter Nourse, 1805-1808
- Samuel Cooper Thacher, 1808-1811
- John Lovejoy Abbot, 1811-1813
- Andrews Norton, 1813-1821
- Joseph Green Cogswell, 1821-1823
- Charles Folsom, 1823-1826
- Benjamin Peirce, 1826-1831
- Thaddeus William Harris, 1831-1856
- John Langdon Sibley, 1856-1877
|