1990s
- 1990 Donald Trump (cameo as himself) - Ghosts Can't Do It
- Leo Damian - Ghosts Can't Do It
- Gilbert Gottfried - The Adventures of Ford Fairlane / Look Who's Talking Too / Problem Child
- Wayne Newton - The Adventures of Ford Fairlane
- Burt Young - Rocky V
- 1991 Dan Aykroyd - Nothing but Trouble
- Richard E. Grant - Hudson Hawk
- Anthony Quinn - Mobsters
- Christian Slater - Mobsters / Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves
- John Travolta - Shout
- 1992 Tom Selleck - Christopher Columbus: The Discovery
- Alan Alda - Whispers in the Dark
- Marlon Brando - Christopher Columbus: The Discovery
- Danny DeVito - Batman Returns
- Robert Duvall - Newsies
- 1993 Woody Harrelson - Indecent Proposal
- Tom Berenger - Sliver
- John Lithgow - Cliffhanger
- Chris O'Donnell - The Three Musketeers
- Keanu Reeves - Much Ado About Nothing
- 1994 O. J. Simpson - Naked Gun 33⅓: The Final Insult
- Dan Aykroyd - Exit to Eden / North
- Jane March (as Richie) - Color of Night
- William Shatner - Star Trek: Generations
- Rod Steiger - The Specialist
- 1995 Dennis Hopper - Waterworld
- Tim Curry - Congo
- Robert Davi - Showgirls
- Robert Duvall - The Scarlet Letter
- Alan Rachins - Showgirls
- 1996 Marlon Brando - The Island of Dr. Moreau
- Val Kilmer - The Ghost and the Darkness / The Island of Dr. Moreau
- Burt Reynolds - Striptease
- Steven Seagal - Executive Decision
- Quentin Tarantino - From Dusk Till Dawn
- 1997 Dennis Rodman - Double Team
- Willem Dafoe - Speed 2: Cruise Control
- Chris O'Donnell - Batman & Robin
- Arnold Schwarzenegger - Batman & Robin
- Jon Voight - Most Wanted / U Turn
- 1998 Joe Eszterhas (as himself) - An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn
- Sean Connery - The Avengers
- Roger Moore - Spice World
- Joe Pesci - Lethal Weapon 4
- Sylvester Stallone (as himself) - An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn
- 1999 Ahmed Best - Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace as Jar Jar Binks
- Kenneth Branagh - Wild Wild West
- Gabriel Byrne - End of Days / Stigmata
- Jake Lloyd - Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace
- Rob Schneider - Big Daddy
Read more about this topic: Golden Raspberry Award For Worst Supporting Actor