2008-2009
First Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Jody Lehman | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Defence | Rod Sarich | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Defence | Steve Munn | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Paul Deniset | Belfast Giants | |
| Forward | David Beauregard | Manchester Phoenix | |
| Forward | Mark Hurtubise | Edinburgh Capitals |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Andrew Verner | Newcastle Vipers | |
| Defence | Jonathan Weaver | Coventry Blaze | |
| Defence | Corey Neilson | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Greg Chambers | Basingstoke Bison | |
| Forward | Adam Calder | Coventry Blaze | |
| Forward | Tony Hand | Manchester Phoenix |
Read more about this topic: EIHL All-Star Team