1990s
- 1990 – Evander Holyfield
- 1991 – James Toney
- 1992 – Riddick Bowe
- 1993 – Pernell Whitaker (2)
- 1994 – George Foreman (2)
- 1995 – Oscar De La Hoya
- 1996 – Evander Holyfield (2)
- 1997 – Evander Holyfield (3)
- 1998 – Shane Mosley
- 1999 – Lennox Lewis
- Fighter of the Decade - Roy Jones, Jr.
Read more about this topic: Edward J. Neil Trophy