1960s
- 1960 – Floyd Patterson (2)
- 1961 – Gene Fullmer
- 1962 – Dick Tiger
- 1963 – Emile Griffith
- 1964 – Willie Pastrano
- 1965 – Muhammad Ali
- 1966 – Dick Tiger (2)
- 1967 – Carlos Ortiz
- 1968 – Bob Foster
- 1969 – Joe Frazier
Read more about this topic: Edward J. Neil Trophy