| Year | Presenter | Award | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Won, "Battle" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Won, "Kings and Queens" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Runner Up (tie), Alexander Koutzoukis, "Kings and Queens" | ||
| 2010 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Won, "Play the Game" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Won, Alexander Koutzoukis, "All the Love in the World" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Won, "Who Are You" | ||
| A cappella Community Awards of CASA | Favorite Male Collegiate Group | Won | |
| Favorite Collegiate Album | Won, "Play the Game" | ||
| Favorite Vocal Percussionist | Runner Up, Alexander Koutzoukis | ||
| Favorite Medley | Runner Up, "The Who Medley" | ||
| 2008 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Won, "Pandaemonium" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Won, Ed Boyer, "Digging in the Dirt" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Won (Tie), "Magical Mystery Tour" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate Soloist | Won, Andrew Savini, "When I Get You Alone" | ||
| 2006 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Won, "Shedding" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Won, Travis Marshall, "Everybody Wants to Rule the World" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Won, "Let's Get It Started" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate Soloist | Won, Andrew Savini, "Epiphany" | ||
| A cappella Community Awards of CASA | Favorite Male Group in the Nation | Won | |
| 2005 | A cappella Community Awards of CASA | Favorite Male Group in the Nation | Won |
| 2004 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Runner Up, "Code Red" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Runner Up, Ed Boyer, "Hot in Herre" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Nominated, "Take Me Home" | ||
| 2002 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Runner-Up, "Next" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Won, Ed Boyer, "Bills, Bills, Bills" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate Soloist | Nominated, Isaac Brody, “Disco Inferno” | ||
| 2000 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Won, "Infinity" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Won, "That’s the Way" | ||
| 1998 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Nominated, Danny Lichtenfield, "I am the Walrus" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Won, "Sledgehammer" from Id | ||
| 1997 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Runner Up, Todd Herzog, "Shape of my Heart" from Drift |
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Runner Up, "With or Without You" | ||
| 1996 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Won, “Gilding” |
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Won, Danny Lichtenfield "Blood of Eden" | ||
| 1995 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Won, Todd Herzog, "Hey You" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Runner Up, "Hey You" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate Soloist | Runner Up, Matt Trowbridge, “The Water is Wide" | ||
| 1994 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Won, "Vince" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Runner Up, Gardner & Herzog, "Sympathy for the Devil" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Won, "Mercy Street" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate Soloist | Won, Todd Herzog | ||
| 1992 | Contemporary a cappella Recording Awards of CASA | Best All-Male Collegiate Album | Won, "Foster Street" |
| Best All-Male Collegiate arrangement | Won, Deke Sharon, "Comfortably Numb/Brain Damage" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate song | Won, "Rio" | ||
| Best All-Male Collegiate Soloist | Won, Todd Herzog |
Read more about this topic: Beelzebubs